Founder of The Bitcoin Layer, Author of Layered Money and Bitcoin Age, teaching at USC Marshall School of Business
Cite asCryptoQuant has tracked the directional calls on SPY by @thebitcoinlayer on Substack since Sep 2021: not yet scored on SPY (as of Nov 18, 2026).
6 SPY calls on record, a thin history.
Relative view by default: fewer than 30 SPY calls or days on record.
Sentiment timeline shows relative sentiment within this analyst's history. A perma-bull showing 8 bullish : 2 bearish in a bear market sets that as their baseline. If you notice any errors, claim @substack:thebitcoinlayer to submit corrections.
Hover the chart to read the thesis of that period · click a day to pin it
Dovish Fed Speak Turned the Bond Market, While the Economy Outside AI Looks Like a Slowdown
TBL Weekly #188: Discussing the US economy, US rates, the AI trade, and Europe, plus some money markets. You can also get access to our charts and data inside our TBL Pulse Dashboard: Get Access to TBL Pulse Dear Readers, This past week, the Fed’s A-team came out to whoop some Treasury-bear butt. As we noted in this article , the President of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York holds a permanent seat at the FOMC (i.e., he doesn’t rotate out like other regional bank Presidents), so his comments carry a great deal of importance for Fed watchers (plus…it’s the New York Fed!). There are also Vice-Chairs in the Board of Governors whose comments are equally important. This past week, New York Fed President John Williams and Vice-Chair Philip Jefferson both took quite the dovish stances. Williams’ Tuesday remark noted : “As I consider the future path of monetary policy, I will continue to assess the underlying trends in inflation and the balance of supply and demand in the economy. With the policy action we took at our September meeting, there is no need for urgency, and we have time to gather more information. ” A dovish tone that was later echoed by Jefferson’s speech on Thursday: “As we look ahead, my view is that any future adjustments in policy should be determined by carefully examining trends in the data, the evolving outlook, and the balance of risks. Since our September meeting, yields across the term structure have increased further, a sign that investors are reassessing the evolving macroeconomic landscape. My colleagues and I will need to come to our own judgment, which may take more time. ” And what better way to assess those underlying inflation trends than the miss we saw in average hourly earnings on Friday, leading to a continued decline in the YoY growth rate: Subscribe now Given the status of these Fed speakers, as well as the employment data we got, the 2-year yield reacted accordingly: Showing just how sensitive the market is to narrative changes (especially those encompassing changes in the short-term rate path), leading SOFR futures to now price in one measly hike by EOY: The following tweet summarizes what we saw this past week quite well: This week’s bullish run happened across the curve, but concentrated in the most Fed-sensitive coupons, leading to a bull steepener in the 2s10s curve for most of the week: This bullish steepening is the market walking back some of the overly hawkish momentum we argued against prior to September’s hike, while also maintaining its growth expectations, even after the Atlanta Fed GDPNow adjusted lower for Q3, from 5% to now 3.7%…with the main drag being net exports: Source Subscribe now In his speech this week, NY Fed President Williams noted: “Real GDP has been growing at about 2 percent for the past year. Productivity growth is running above pre-pandemic levels. And business investment has surged, powered by the ever-increasing AI buildout. Expectations of solid growth and high productivity have, in turn, fueled stock market gains, leading to robust consumer spending, particularly from higher-income households and homeowners.” This was once again echoed by Vice-Chair Jefferson later in the week: “[S]pending at retailers accelerated somewhat in the first half of this year. I continue, however, to hear anecdotal evidence of elevated price sensitivity and softening consumer demand, especially for low-income consumers.” This feeds further into a view that we’ve been developing over some time now. Consumption by the lower end of the K-shaped economy is dodgy. And if the wealth effect is carrying the consumption for those higher-income individuals, then looking at the S&P 500 versus its equal-weighted index doesn’t necessarily leave me feeling jolly about spending: In other words, consumption is itself basically tied down to this large AI trade. Even jobs are showing strength in AI-specific sectors. Residential construction jobs are diverging from non-residential construction work, pointing to AI-dependency, even for blue-collar workers: This whole thing seems like an economic slowdown outside of AI. And even when looking deeper into the AI CapEx story, AI investment is slowly being eaten up by nominal increases in raw goods, so what good is seeing “Trillion-Dollar” stimulative CapEx headlines when an increasing portion of this spending is simply trying to keep up with COGS: Subscribe now Combine all of these economic dynamics, but remove energy exports, AI dominance, and a cohesive economy, and you end up with something like Europe’s current outlook, with markets cracking under pressure: Being the commodity importer that it is, Europe is struggling. What’s more, how much of an AI edge does Europe have? Asian economies like Japan (or Korea) can justify their fiscal situation by, at the very least, having AI to show for it. But Europe? How does the ECB manage a thousand non-cohesive economic dynamics? Mind you, I am not an expert in what’s happening over there, so I welcome feedback and comments that correct my bearish view on Europe’s economy as a whole, especially in this AI-driven world. As it stands right now, however, it seems like its economy is kind of where the US stands, but without the AI tailwinds that are carrying this whole boom. Leave a comment Before we keep going, I’d like to give credit to the Forward Guidance podcast and their latest guest. I couldn’t have written this piece without input from their latest episode . Tons of great charts and quality analysis. A Money Markets Update Lastly, we simply cannot leave a quarter-end without addressing money markets. We look closely at USTs, but that means nothing without a continued watch of the plumbing. Q3 was the first quarter this year where we had one month with zero reserve management purchases (RMPs) by the New York Fed: Source The decision to slow down reserve management operations came after a few notable events. Firstly, since September 2025, cumulative bill issuance has been on the rise, while money markets stress (as measured by the SOFR-IORB spread) has remained below 0…for the most part: Source A sign that money markets aren’t as tight as they were starting out the year (largely thanks to RMPs). Another big component is the projections of cash in the TGA. In its most recent QRA , the Treasury wrote, “[d]uring the October–December 2026 quarter, Treasury expects to borrow $628 billion in privately-held net marketable debt, assuming an end-of-December cash balance of $850 billion : To which, in a recent speech , SOMA manager Roberto Perli responded, “our forecast for reserve supply did change materially as we updated it to reflect Treasury’s guidance for the end-of-December level of the Treasury General Account (TGA), which was lower than we had previously assumed.” A.k.a., more reserves in the system than previously anticipated. Roberto also noted that the Fed’s decisions on RMPs are informed by “[their] assessment of reserve demand, [their] forecast for reserve supply, and both current and expected money market conditions.” So they are watching both the SOFR-IORB spread on month-end or T-bill auction dates, as well as their standing repo facility, which, not surprisingly, popped this quarter-end, helping to maintain the SOFR-IORB spread flat: Working exactly as intended. The fact that SRF popped as soon as RMPs reduced to zero tells me that we are in an ample reserve regime (not an abundant one). Hence, Perli and the Fed “ stand ready to adjust them again in the future to fulfill the FOMC’s policy to keep reserves within the ample range. ” Without RMPs, our SRF watch is back on, with one eye on the SOFR-IORB spread while the other on the SRF for any signs that continued facility usage is unable to maintain SOFR below IORB. Side note: we do expect stress in the near future due to a technical transition in how overnight markets clear, but we’ll reserve that topic for another time. Second side note: the fourth quarter brings the most stress on money markets as the financial sphere attempts to roll all financing to January. Subscribe now Share Leave a comment Substack This Week Nik addressed his take on the increasingly important BTC/Gold ratio in his letter this Tuesday: As per usual, Johan helps us ground our price expectations for bitcoin , and he’s absolutely killing the levels; the latest in his Wednesday letter: I also dive deeper into what’s happening in Europe with Nik in our Thursday recording: YouTube This Week Nik recorded a deep-dive video on Tuesday that goes over a lot of our charts and the framework that we’re working on here at TBL, especially TBL Liquidity , which was extremely informative for my own outlooks: Nik also addresses the cracks in the European bond market in Wednesday’s video: On Friday, Nik goes discusses bitcoin’s performance amidst what is going on in bonds: Which is built upon further in Johan’s conversation with Pascal from Less Noise More Signal on Friday, where they discuss how bitcoin fits within this European market crisis : For Podcast Listeners Our videos are on major podcast platforms—take us with you on the go! Apple Podcasts Spotify Keep up with The Bitcoin Layer by following our social media! YouTube X LinkedIn Disclaimer The TBL Model Portfolio, TBL Liquidity Indicator, and all TBL research outputs reflect Nik Bhatia and team’s analytical positioning for the macro and bitcoin environment. They are published for educational purposes only and are not investment advice, not a solicitation to buy or sell securities, and not a recommendation tailored to any individual’s portfolio. The Bitcoin Layer is not a registered investment advisor and does not manage client money. Please consult a professional financial advisor and conduct independent due diligence before making investment decisions.
View original →TBL Weekly #181: Is the US Economy Feeling The Pinch?
Market breadth may need to carry the US consumer You can get access to our charts and data inside our TBL Pulse Dashboard: Get Access to TBL Pulse Dear Readers, Another summer week is done…where has 2026 gone? It’s almost September! As I wrote in a letter two weeks ago, with both tax season and the World Cup coming to an end, I have been cautiously bullish on the US economy. With a diminishing savings rate, tax refunds out of the way, and the World Cup retail sales pump fading, there are fewer consumer spending sources during the second half of 2026. This has had me fading the bearish narrative currently plaguing US Treasuries. Sentiment out there is placing too much emphasis on inflation…almost forgetting that labor is not necessarily shining. I will copy what I said on August 1st : Subscribe now The Fed is already tightening Not only is the labor market showing signs of cooling, but the Fed is technically tightening despite maintaining its policy rate unchanged. Have a look at the San Francisco Fed’s “Proxy Fed Funds Rate,” something I discussed inside our TBL Pulse Community this week: Source As the Fed writes , “[t]he proxy rate uses financial market data to infer the broad stance of monetary policy as determined by funds rate changes, forward guidance about projected future rates, and balance sheet changes.” And although forward guidance is out the window now, balance sheet conditions are still baked into the proxy. SOMA Tightening The US Treasury’s most recent QRA statement reiterated that it is monitoring T-bill SOMA purchases as a source of demand for issuance at the very short end of the curve. This is arguably one of the main culprits for the proxy Fed funds rate appearing higher than the current policy rate (chart above). Not because it is buying T-bills, but because of what it’s trading for them. That’s where the tightening is happening, really. As the Fed reinvests long-term assets (think MBS) into the short-end of the curve (T-bills), you see SOMA’s weighted-average maturity fall (chart below): Chart on TBL Pulse This is something the Fed has wanted to do for a while now…more on this shortly. For now, suffice it to say that, as the Fed transitions into shorter-term securities, its thumb on the scale of duration risk is less heavy. It is effectively leaving the private market to absorb any duration on its own (a.k.a., a form of tightening). As Warsh put it in his most recent meeting, the market is doing his tightening for him. Subscribe now A short sidequest here: Why does the Fed want SOMA WAM down? There are many reasons for wanting to bring WAM down, and Fed watchers will either agree or disagree with me here. But my take narrows it down to a couple reasons. Malleability (or market neutrality) and operating losses. A malleable balance sheet: Shorter-term assets make the Fed’s balance sheet a lot more flexible. It could allow it to enter duration (think large-scale asset purchases) without massively altering the size of the balance sheet, since T-bills mature faster and provide a source of cash without ‘printing.’ Shorter-term assets can also allow it to reduce the size of its balance sheet without impacting market duration. The goal is ultimately to become more market neutral. Operating losses : Simply, when the Fed is paying a higher interest on reserves than it gets from its long-, low-yielding Treasuries (that it bought back in 2020, for example), it is losing. T-bills adjust upward with IORB. Anyway, back to the article… The US Economy To summarize, the Fed is tighter than most think. Even our own TBL Liquidity Index has experienced a slowdown this year (albeit still in the expansionary territory of above 50 and showing signs of improvement): Chart on TBL Pulse Subscribe now The market is coming to terms with these existing tighter conditions. After this week’s highly anticipated CPI print, the results of which were largely benign (at expectations), the market started to take its foot off the ‘hiking’ pedal. Then PPI’s cooler-than-expected print came in as a double-whammy. December 2026 one-month SOFR futures surged this week, implying lower hiking expectations by EOY: If you want the US economy to continue Rock-and-Rolling, hikes are probably not the move. You need a continuation of the consumer spending boosts that we saw during 1H26. Retail sales on Friday continued to build on this idea that 2H26 will be a lot slower for the consumer. The results for July were MUCH cooler than expected. The control group (which is baked into GDP calculations) missed big, coming in at -0.4% versus the expected +0.3% MoM: There’s a lot of seasonality in these numbers, of course. The Bank of America expected these lower numbers for similar reasons that we did: post-World-Cup effects. So, the question is: where’s the next boost to consumption coming from? For now, I place my bets on risk assets. T he stock market could “self-fulfillingly” be that very source of strength the consumer needs… Risk Is Not Really Feeling the Slowdown Despite the labor market slowing (which is a headwind for consumption), we also see a lot more market breadth. The equal-weight S&P 500 made a new ATH this week: From our MCP Server To paraphrase Fidelity , during the last rally in 1999, only 20% of stocks were above their 200-day moving average. Today, that figure is approximately 74% (chart below): Source Moreover, Q2’s earnings surpassed expectations. As Bloomberg puts it : Overall, 85.2% of companies exceeded Wall Street’s EPS expectations through Monday’s close, which is the highest percentage since 2021[...]. There is market breadth, so don’t sleep on the wealth effect to carry the US consumption picture. The wealth effect, or just very good marketing from movie producers. Have a look at box office grosses lately: I already watched The Odyssey (6.5/10, in my humble opinion), and will be watching Spider-Man this weekend. Anyway, in all seriousness, what I am trying to say is the consumer has clearly not gone anywhere; I simply need to see some more economic tailwinds. This is why I say I am cautiously bullish on the US economy…and why I understand some US rates traders placing short butterfly trades on the curve (going long 2s and 30s, and short 10s). Bullish 2s because the hiking story is overdone, bullish 30s because the back-end could be in dip-buying territory, but hedging against a strong US economy by shorting 10s. Subscribe now The AI Race As the East versus West AI race continues, we are seeing declines in the LLM Token Expenditure Index, which, as Silicon Data puts it , tells you how much the AI market is paying for a million LLM tokens (regardless of the model). This past week, the model declined nearly 10%: Source Some narratives out there argue that this recent decline in price could be ascribed to Chinese models (like Kimi from Moonshot AI) competing with American models. We unfortunately don’t have full access to this Silicon Data index, but if any of you do, please post it in our Community . I, for one, would love to see the overall trend over the past few months at least. Either way, there’s clear competition for end-use market share in AI, which is beneficial for consumers like us, who end up paying less for tokens. However, I don’t know about you guys, but my computer has been barely keeping up with the amount of stuff I need it to do now that I am using Claude Code daily. Cheap tokens are great and all, but as the price of tokens decreases, usage could inversely increase, which leads to users demanding new and better hardware. July’s CPI print showed us that computer prices surged on a monthly basis: Source We even saw Intel offer equity this week for the first time in 55 years to capitalize on this AI boom…which wasn’t great for our SOXX ETF inside our Model Portfolio at the start of the week, but Intel ended up recovering from those dilution fears. All this to say, I am not blind to the fact that AI inflation pressures remain. What I am watching is whether the consumer has the funds to keep up with rising prices and consumption overall, and if they don’t, then higher interest rates can really harm this AI-led economy. Subscribe now Substack This Week Nik’s letter went out on Monday; and Johan’s weekly letter went out on Wednesday. YouTube This Week This week Demian brought back a very special guest for TBL, Joe Consorti, to discuss the Clarity Act: For Podcast Listeners Here are the links to our latest episode: SPOTIFY APPLE Our videos are on major podcast platforms—take us with you on the go! Apple Podcasts Spotify Keep up with The Bitcoin Layer by following our social media! YouTube X LinkedIn Disclaimer The TBL Model Portfolio, TBL Liquidity Indicator, and all TBL research outputs reflect Nik Bhatia and team’s analytical positioning for the macro and bitcoin environment. They are published for educational purposes only and are not investment advice, not a solicitation to buy or sell securities, and not a recommendation tailored to any individual’s portfolio. The Bitcoin Layer is not a registered investment advisor and does not manage client money. Please consult a professional financial advisor and conduct independent due diligence before making investment decisions.
View original →